the spectre of mental illness has always haunted human history

the spectre of mental illness has always haunted human history

Kings that went mad and became megalomaniacs (some even going so far as to declare themselves to be God, and then demanding to be worshipped). Religious zealots, or fanatics, who did not (or would not) govern their religious fervor with reason.  Deranged sociopaths that murder and traffic in mayhem.  Delusional utopian Marxists who murdered tens of millions of human beings in the 20th century (here many would object, and label these bloodthirsty tyrants as evil, not insane).  Power hungry, shallow, yet narcissistic community organizers.  Enough examples.

There is a very relevant question lurking here:  What constitutes true mental illness, and what is just pure old-fashioned evil?  The question is not an idle one, nor intended to be an exercise in philosophical speculation.  There are important real world implications here.

If one is truly suffering from serious mental illness, then he or she is not (fully) responsible for his/her actions, but still would need to be confined in a controlled setting if they are violent and dangerous to others and/or to themselves.  If they are mentally competent, not seriously mentally ill, these violent, destructive individuals will be dealt with in the existing criminal justice system (that may need serious reform or restructuring).

Resources, nowadays, often are available to help diagnose and treat such baneful psychoses.  But, psychiatry – it needs to be said – does not have all the answers, nor is it likely ever to possess all the “answers”.  Drugging and sedating individuals in an effort to control their behavior, except in extremely violent cases, is a risky and dangerous path to embark upon, or to continue along.

But, how does one know that he or she is mentally ill, or becoming so?  How can a person recognize the warning signs in themselves?  How can others, close to such a person, recognize the red flags of approaching danger?  Anyone who listens to the news regularly hears of multiple murders, suicides, and not infrequently of multiple murder-suicides where one person kills others (usually family members or co-workers), and then kills himself.  The news reports sometimes indicate that there were existing problems that were known to others, but in other cases it is noted that there were no indications of existing stresses or mental illness that would lead to outbreaks of such violence and destruction.

Perhaps, there is an unrecognized collective psychosis in today’s society that too many individuals are suffering from, albeit they are unaware of its presence and symptoms.

Just food for thought.  We don’t claim to have the answers either.  But, these questions ought to be given consideration.

3 thoughts on “the spectre of mental illness has always haunted human history

  1. Larry the real problem is that mental illness does manifest itself to people around them. The problem is that there is no reporting apparatus and the libs voted to disband mental hospitals because of “patient rights”. That leaves the loony tunes free to wander at will often endangering themselves and others around them. The Army major was
    displaying signs of mental illness to his superiors as well as subordinates long before he went on the killing spree. Because of political correctness that we can’t suspect muslims of anything he was left “hands off”. Again the libs are responsible for most of our societal problems because of their “do gooder” mentality

    • The army major who committed the Fort Hood, Texas massacre was evil. I will not give him a pass because of current political correctness. We need to recognize the truth in this troubled society. Regrettably, many folks are incapable of doing so. Many others opt to remain in a state of denial as they have too much of an emotional investment in “liberal orthodoxy”.

      The ascendancy of modern liberalism with all its ne’er do wells, is responsible for making many existing problems worse, and for giving rise to new ones. It truly is a scourge.

      But, that was not the thrust of the above essay.

  2. Pingback: Our best, most helpful essays and links | larrysmusings

Leave a Reply

Fill in your details below or click an icon to log in:

WordPress.com Logo

You are commenting using your WordPress.com account. Log Out / Change )

Twitter picture

You are commenting using your Twitter account. Log Out / Change )

Facebook photo

You are commenting using your Facebook account. Log Out / Change )

Google+ photo

You are commenting using your Google+ account. Log Out / Change )

Connecting to %s